美国法制现代化的历史逻辑——对《美国法律史》的解读

美国法制现代化的历史逻辑——对《美国法律史》的解读 美国法制现代化的历史逻辑——对《美国法 律史》的解读 3 , ???????B?????f?4???4???p?????4?f???????????????4????,?4???[???????????k?????? ???4????T1?k???9?B???????(,???????????????????r?B??????,?4?????????????????)?? ?????????4????,???8???????l?????4???????????B???o????T1 ???v??T?????T????B?????fT????????? ?k???????4?(,???????B?????f?4???4???p?????4?f???????????????4????,?4???[???????????k?? ???????4????T1?k???9?B???????(,???????????????????r?B??????,?4?????????????????)?????????? ?4????,???8???????l?????4???????????B???o????T1?k??????,???4?T???1?k???????????;T(?A??T7T,?? ?4?T???w???B????T,???w?????????????aT1?????Y?????5,????????????????????T1???S,?????????,?? ????????????????????,?????????]?]??????????????????T1?T19?f??30????,???w?????]?????????? ????T119?f??60???????Y???5,?????B????????????????T1????20?f???(???.,??????????????????, ???F?]?]????????????T1?????????????????7????,?S???????????k?kT(??????????T7?C?6???????????] ?????????????6?]???D?B??:???????.T,???]???.T,?????????????.T,???p???????.?????????.T1???????? ?f??T(?f?????B??T7?6?????????B?????]?????????????6?]???4?T???.????????T,?????Y???5????????T, ???N?Y???5????????T,???????.????????T1TF1Ty ?k?4???7??,?????????6?.?????????3?D?B???????????? ???L?6T1?l??,?????????????????6?????D???.,?u???B???S???4?T???.,???S???????B?????f???????B ??,???????S???????B?????f??????????,?????????i???S???????B?????f??????????;?u???B???S???? ?Y???T???N?Y?????????????????]???.;?u?;?B??,???N?Y???5?T19?f???b???????B???]?????.;?u???B ???S20?f?????????????????????????.T1 ??T,???4?T???.(1607iF1783):???????B?????f???????B?? ?????????S?????????4?T,ie??????????????????1607???????u???d?k?N?;?????????????????? ?4inT1TF2Ty ?8?????2?????????k?N?????4??????????T1???S,???????w???????????????aT,?????????????? ????????T,?????B?????7??T,?????B???????????4?????N???hT1 ??3?? 3 1Ty TFTy ??????,?????:?9?o????????????,?????.???:T1 ?????????????f:T(?f?????B??T7,?C?????4?o????????1999????,?u176178??;?l?????f??T(?f?????B??T7?6???????????]?????? ???????L?6???;?D?B??:???4?T???.??????T,???w????????T,???Y???????f??????????????T1(?????l?????f:T(?f?????B??T7,?N???o ????????2000????,318322??T1)??????T,?????0???f??T(?f?????B??T7?6???????????]?????????????6?]???D?B??:???????????? (6iF5??)T,???????????](6iF6??)T,????????????(6iF?f???b)T,????????????(?f???niF????)T1(?????? ????T,?????0T(?f?????B??T7,?)???o????????????,?u3??T1) [??]?????????(T(????????????T7,?N???o????????????,?u??T1 9 2 1071771771811811920 :200221822 :19971 1608?????F?????H?????????????a,?????????k???????4?T?????.??,TF3Ty ???817?f???T18?f ???C???????S???????w???k???4?T???N?[???.T1???????.,???????B???????H???????k???4?T???;???? ????T1?B?8,?l???????????????;???o???d????,???????k???4?T???1?k?9?????[,???????4?T,???1?k?? ?????????;T(?A??T7T,???4?T???w???B????T,???w?????????????aT1???C???4?T???w?B?????????????;: 1620??T(???p?0?????:????????T7T,1639??T(???????????u??T7T,1639??T(?????????4???l???p????T7T,1641 ??T(???k?????????l????T7T,1668??T(???y???????????o??T7??T1?????????????1?k???????????S?w????, ???C,???????)?????1?????4?T?????????S????????T1 ????,?????????)?????9?????????)?????????7??,?????o???????M?????????????M?w??????????, ?8?????????4?T???4???.?????????i?k????????T,???:,???????;?????w????????,?????????3???????v ???????T,????,?k???4?T????ie?????(?)???k?????????????)?9???????f???????????????.?(,???w?? ?S?)??????????inT1TF4Ty ???d,???????.???4?T???w?????????w?)????,?)???2???)???????????w????T1??????ie???4?T???? ?;?????w?????????u????,?????????????????????3???)?8???????;?????????)?9???????]??T1inTF5Ty ???h ???4?T???????o?????B?????T?????T?6????,??????????????????????,ie?????s???;?????w???k?????? ?????????????????y???]???)????inT1TF6Ty ???d,???.???4???????????????r?????]?????????w?????)?p???iT1???.???4?C?;???w?S???????l ?????????????8???T???o??????????,???8?????????w?????????B?????;????????T1?k?????7??,???4?T ???4???????S???????????l?????p,?8?)?S???D???w?????9????T1TF7Ty ?k???????????r???C,?????????? ???.??????,?????w???A??????????????T1 18?f???C?????5,????????T,?????????f??????,???4?T??????????????,?k?????????(?1?k??????T1 ?k???????w?????????(,?N???????4?T???????k?????????????[,?;?????k?????????[???????w??;?k?? ???????????????(,???k????T,???y???????????4?T?)??????????,?????l???w?????????1?k?????????? ?6????;??????????T,?N????????T,????????T,??????T,????T,??????T,???????????4?T?a???;?M?????????? ???????1?k???????????????6????T1?k?????????B????????,?3???4?T?w?????????5???????B?????k?? ?4?T?;??T1?9???????w??T(??????????T7?k????????,???????v???????????i??,???w?????k???????4?T ?C???????????T??T1???????????;:?u??,18?f???C??,?????????????w?????????)???????????.????, ???????3?T??????????????,?????1???]?????],???.???)?????w????????,???w???M???????????C???? ?????????????????????)??,???)?S???;?????????9????????????T1?k?????????7,?????)?????4?T???4 ???7???????????w???????????4?T???????????????kT1?u??,?????????????????4?T??????,???????N?? ???4?T??????????,???????????k???4?T?????(???,T1?k?????(,?????????0???????4?T???;????,?)?? ?????????????w???;???8????????,?8?????B???????????aT1?;???????????????????T?????????a,?3?? ?4?T???w?B????????????????????????????,?)???5??????????,?t?a?l?????9????T1??????,??1696iF 1776??,?????????????t???????4?T?????)?4??400??T1TF8Ty ?k?????(,???????????????????4?T?????? ?(????????T1?k?????(?????????????????B???4?T??????????T1?k???w???i?????8???k?7,???????k?N ?????4?T?]?]???????S???T??,???4?T???????;?????o????,?????????B?????]???7????????????T1 ???? ????????????T?2009???s???? TF3Ty TF4Ty TF5Ty TF6Ty TFTy TFTy ????[??]????????????:T(????????????????T7,?(????????????1984????,?u372??T1 [??]????????????:T(????????????????T7,?(????????????1984????,?u373??T1 [??]?S???????????k:T(??????????T7,?C???????o????????1990????,?u19??T1 [??]?S???????????kT(??????????T7,?C???????o????????????,?u??T1 ????[??]?S???????????kT(??????????T7,?C???????o????????????,?u??T1 ?????????AT(????????T7,?C????????????,?u??T1 49 7 8 :19902021 :199012 :197028 (1783iF1861):???????B?????]?B?? ????????????????????????????????????????,???????????.???5???????????b?????????kT1???? ???.,?k???????????d?[?(,?????l?????????]?????????????r?B?0,?T?????????????????????]?????? ?????r?B?0?????????7T1 ?????Y???T19?f???(????,?????????k?????.???C???????????T??T1ie?????????k?3?D?????????; ?Y???T??,?S???D???.???????2??T1???????????????u???S???????w?B?????????0T1?????k???4?T???? ?????????.???????C???s?????k,?????????T?????;?:???oT1?k??????,???4?T?????????)???S???????? ?????n???.?????????????(???7????????T1inTF9Ty ?k?????5?????????.??,???????????;???????,?rT1?k?????4?N????,???????????????5?????????? ??T1?8??,???????????????????????o?????,,???w?;???B?????2???????1????????,?;???5?????6???M ??????,?3???w???????;?m????,?????????]???B???????????????,????T1ie?k???D???????]???.,???? ?????????????????S????????????????,???????S?????????C?????v?o??????T1inTF10Ty ?????6?????a?k?3?? ?????o?????C?????T?????[??????,?????;???????????????????????????C,ie?k19?f???????.,?????? ??????,?????S????,?k?????6?????????[?(,???????????.?AT1inTF11Ty ?8?????????????????????????????? ??,?l???????????H?????;???????????k??T1???f,???.???????????k???????????????????????????)?? ??T1???????????w???B???????9?????f?????H??;?k?H?????5?????????????H;?k?(???.?????5???????( ????;???????????l???????9?????????l????????;???????m???????6?k?????(????????;???????????? ???:???o;?C???????;?????B?D?b????????????????;?2???????????k?7???D?????.???6;???????v???? ???m??,????????????????;?H???????????????b?????w;???????????????????????????????????????A ??????T1???????????????T1846??,???????????????????T1857??,???)???????(????????T1???y???? ?????????????T1847?????)??????????????????????T1???w?????T19?f???b???)???????l?D?b?????? ?w????????????T1???????????????????????????7,???????????????????w?????(?T?????S???????5??, ?????8??,?????????3???????????????????T??T1TF12Ty ?k???????.,?3?????????????????????S?B?????o????ie????????inT1????ie????????in???B?????T?? ???????4???????????0???,??????,?8?????9???T???????????]?????????w?.????????????????T1???? ?Y???5?????????.,?l?????????k??????????????,?????????????T????T1?????????????(???2??:ie?? ?????????)?p???1?k???????????????kT1?;?????????????y?k?????5?????????????H??in,TF13Ty 1787???? ?????????????????5???5???????i????????????T1???B,?k?????????????????,???(,?3?D?????k?;???) ?8???[???????iT1???w?????k?????????[?????S?t????????????????????T1??????,?;?????w???????? ???T????????????,??????????1799?????????????????????????C?1?k?????y??????,???????????k 1891??????????;TF14Ty ????????1808?????w???????????k???????????????y?k?????????????????????? ???????H??T1???y???????????????9???F???????9????????????T1TF15Ty ????????,?;?????a?w??ie?????? ??in???[?????????????u???????????????]???6T1??1786?????????w?????????????????w???????????k ?????;??,1821??????????????????,???;?)?????????????w?????a?????k?????????1?kT1TF16Ty ??5?? ???????B?????f?????????? TF9Ty TF10Ty TF11Ty TF12Ty TF13Ty TFTy TF5Ty TF6Ty [??]?S???????????k:T(??????????T7,?C???????o????????1990????,?u77??T1 [??]?S???????????k:T(??????????T7,?C???????o????????1990????,?u7778??T1 [??]?S???????????k:T(??????????T7,?C???????o????????1990????,?u78??T1 ????[??]?S???????????k:T(??????????T7,?C???????o????????1990????,?u7879??T1 [??]?????????(:T(????????????T7,?N???o????????1997????,?u1??T1 LMF,yfL,NY,5, ????[??]?S???????????kT(??????????T7,?C???????o????????????,?u5??T1 LMF,yfL,NY,5, 9 14 1 1 awrence.riedmanAHistoroAmericanawework198pp.111112 :1990141 awrence.riedmanAHistoroAmericanawework198pp.111. ,???]?????i?????w???????????????????B???????????i???????????d?[?f???]?????? ??????;?n?.?]?????????????o,?????3?????????)?4????T1?k?p?k?]???????f???w???i?????????7???? ??,??????????????????T11847??,???????]?????l?O????D?????F?????????????????????w,???????? ?????????aT,?????7????????????T,????T,???f,??1865?????5?B????T(?4??????????T7T,T(?4??????????T7T, T(?4????T7T,T(?4????T7??T(????????T7,????ie???F??????inT1ie???B?????p???????????????????D?????k?? T(?4????T7??T(????????T7,?????F?????????????????f?????????????(???l?s??T1inTF17Ty ?????f???????]?l ???S?;????,?l???????????]?????????w?C?)???f????????????,?????????B?S??????????????,ie???? ???B???k????????????,?y?k???????H??,???6???????????H?????????,?8???????yT1inTF18Ty ???5???S???w ???????????p,???????????k??:?u??,?8???????4??????????????,?????????????????]?]?M??;?u??,?8 ?????????k???w??????????,?l?????8??,?k????????T,???????????????n?????w?????;?????Y????T1 ?????????????;?????S?????k,???S???D???????u????????????????,???????.????????????????, ???????????????;?B???????;???????????r?i?o????T1???5?8?.?????H???????.?????.????????,?S?? ????????T1?k???????????]???.,???w???w?????????????o?l????T1TF19Ty ???????????????????;????T,?? ?S????T,???F?)??????????????,?????w?;?????b????????T,?????F???????????????????????5???????? ???0,???S???????????????w?S????????????T1?;?????????????????????f??????????????,?i?]?????? ?????????????sT1ie????,?????????l?l???????????????;?i??,?l???????????4???????????????:???? ?k??????T1???f???n?????????????????2?????)?????????)??????????????T119?f??40????,?????? ???????????6?3???????????????k?o???7???o?????B????????????????T1inTF20Ty ???????????k???T?????7 ???????F???????f???????l?p,??????????19?f?????????????????7?C???????????????????????k,?? ?8???????????????6???????????w?????????????4??????T1 19?f??????,?????????]?]???]?????;????????????,???????????????????????a?]?]?]???????? ???.?????D???u?6??T1???????????????3???????????????????????????]?????????????r?i?0T1?????? ????????????????,???????????????????o??????????T1?k?????????i?????????????(???]???????u?. ?????n??,???????C?????????????????)?????n????????T1 ?u??,???????????)?????????]?]??????????????????????,???k???????(?)?????o????????????T1?? ???w??1792????????????(HayburnπsCase)???????????????????????9??,???5,???w??1803???????S???? ?????(??(Marburyv.Madison)?????????????????????????????S?t????????????T1?????F?????????????? ?????????????????H???????[?]?]???????3??????????,?????H??????????????????????????,???????,?? ?????)??????T1?5?????????????????????????o??????,?????????k???????????????????)???T???o,1842 ???????,?b??????????(Swiftv.Tyson)?S?????????????????????o?????7??,?[?????????????k???6???? ???????)?????3?????????8?S???????????u???a??????,?????????????????????????fT1 ?u??,?????????????]?????????,????????,?????????????????]?????????????C??T1?????????????? ?k?????????????9?????w?????B????????,?k?????7???(???????:???3????????,?????????????aT,?????? ???????????2?(??????T119?f???C??,?3???????????????f???????????????B,???????????????????B???? ???w?????????????p???????????u???a?????BT1?5???8??,?3???????.???????????????????????k?o???7 ???o?????BT1???S,19?f?????????H???]?????????????]??????????,?H?????]?????????????????C???? ??T1???????????????????i?????w??,?????????????????k?w???????H???????????????????2????T1TF21Ty ?u?;,?????w?????????????H?????????????????????????aT1?O???????????????,??,?S?????????? ??6?? ????????????T?2009???s???? TF17Ty TF18Ty TFTy TFTy TFTy [??]?S???????????k:T(??????????T7,?C???????o????????1990????,?u86??T1 LawrenceM.Friedman,AHistoryofAmericanLaw,NewYork,1985,pp.112. ????[??]?S???????????kT(??????????T7,?C???????o????????????,?u??T1 [??]?S???????????kT(??????????T7,?C???????o????????????,?u??T1 ????[??]?S???????????kT(??????????T7,?C???????o????????????,?u??T1 9 19 20 21 :199080 :199082 :199082 ,?????????????????????????l?)???T?4?????i??????????T1 ?k???,???????????????????????N?;?????????????H???C???????????????(?????a,???5,?k1819???? ???9?r??????????(McCullochv.Maryland)??1842?????;?7????????????(Gibbonsv.Ogden)?????? ?;?p ?????????D???;???C?v?????????????????aT1???9?r?????????????????H??,???????w???;?????????? ???????????a,???w???????T??????????????,?????;?????????????)??????????T1?????????????,???? ???????4?8???3??,???????????????????????????4????????T1?k?;?7?????????????H???C,?????F???? ?????????u?????u?????????M???M,???)?S?????????????w,???w???????w?????B???)???3?????????? ?B,?8?????0?????5???????????w????T1?l?????????w?????w?????????.????,???8???w?????????w???? ?????S??????????????T1?????????????w???????H???????d?????????????????a,?????3???)???????? ???w???o?????l????????????????,?????????w???????????k???????9?????w??????T1TF22Ty ???????5,?? ???????????w?????????M????T,???????a????T,?????7???????????????????a?????????????o???????? ??,?????????????????aT1 ???5,19?f?????????????????????6????????,???????????????]????????????????T11784???????? ???b???????????????u??????????????iFiFiF?p?????F????????,?????????T1833??,?5???????T???????? ??????????????????,?????]?????????????????????????(??T1?5???8??,?3?o??????????????????????T1 1817???????????????????2?????????o??????????????????????,???????M?w???????????????????:,?]?? ?????M?w?f??????????????T11829??,?o?????????????????????????????u???????,??,???????????????u ?????????:?????????d?????????7??????????,??1830?????5???????????????????7????????????T1???? ?Y??,????????????????20?D????T11835???u???5??F?????????k?????1?o??????????????,???r???M?w?? ????????,?5?????????????????]???????????????7??????????,?????????k?7??T1TF23Ty ?5?????1??,?????? ???????????????????]???????T???.??????T1????T,??????T,?????p?bT,?y???????????S?????????????:?? ????????????????????????,?;???8?????????i??,???,?????5???????????????f??T1?????????????????? ?]???s?????o?????kT1?k?S???????????k?7??,ie???;????????????,???w???S?t?????????p?T???T????,?f ?0?????H???S?t???]?????????????C???????S??????????T1?k???D???v???.,?6?????????????????????? ???????w???????,?o???5????????,????,?l?????????????????????r????????????T1inTF24Ty ?;T,???N?Y?????5:???????B???]???B?? ???N?Y?????5,???????u???????T?????.????,???4?????B?????d,??????,?????(?5?????6???8???( ??????????????,?????????????????????????????w??,???k?????w??T,?????????B???????i?????[,???? ???l???????????B??T1?k?????B??,ie???????????S?????????????;?????????w?????s?????????????k ?????m??T1inTF25Ty ???8,???????????????w?S???D???.?????????????2T1 ???N?Y?????p?5,?????????B?????????T??????????????,???????????u????????????????,?????w ?????????????????????????i,???????l?,???????w???4?????B??????????????T11865???????????B?? ?u???;???????????????[?.??,?2???????????????(?????u????????T,???????????????????????7T1 ?????u???;???????????????B??????,?????4???p?????????0?????????(??????,???????????????? ???????4???p???4?f???????????????4????T1ie1868???2?????????????????D??????:?u14?????????? ??????????????T1???4???p???4?f??,?????B???????3?T??????????,???.??T,???l???m???????????6?? ????T1?u14?????????]???????w???k???p???k???????w?C??????????????????????????????????T1?? ???? ???????B?????f?????????? TF22Ty TF3Ty TFTy TF5Ty ?????????????f:T(?f??????:??????????T7,?N???o????????2004????,?u1529??T1 ????[??]?S???????????kT(??????????T7,?C???????o????????????,?u6??T1 [??]?S???????????kT(??????????T7,?C???????o????????????,?u6??T1 [??]?S???????????kT(??????????T7,?C???????o????????????,?u6??T1 79 2 24 2 :1990949 :19909 :199019 ,?k???w????,???p???????o???????S???k?u14?????????C???v?o???????(??????T1inTF26Ty ?????u14?? ?????????ST(????????T7??????????????????????,?S?????????????;?????????????????????s??T1???? ?????????????????????6?????????????T??????????,???k?????]???D?????p???o????,?]???????D???? ?l??????T1?????????u????????:ie?3?????)???B???f?????????:?N?????4???????5????????????,?)?? ?D?????????????7???8?????????????.??T,???l?f?m??,?????k???????9????????????,?)???????????? ????????????T1in?B?8,?k???n???B??,?u14???????????????????????S??????????,???????(?]?????Y ???5?????l???u??????????????T1 ?u14??????????????????,?[???????????????????.???????????????4?????D?????p?????4???fT1 ???D?L???????????k???????????????i?]???????p?????????5?????????????????????4???p?????f???H ?D???o???????5??T1?k???N?Y??????,?3???S?u?????4???p????????,?3?????????????????p???o?k???9 ??T1?????????????k???6???t?????F?????1?????1???w????????????,?u???????????????1?k???????? ??,T(???p????T7?u???????????????;??????,???3??????????T1???l?[????,?D?????p?;???????T?????? ?????[????T1?u14???????????????????????2,?6?D?????p???????????????9??,???????4?????????? ???????????????7?????]???3???????????B???h?9T1 ???N?Y???5???????????????0???????5????????,???????wie?w???1????????in???????????????? ??,???8?????w?B???4????????????????????T1???????w???B????T(1866???4??????T7?????0???????k?? ?????4????????T,?????????????;?m???????4???p????,???k???????u14???????????S?,T11870?????u ?????????????????????????;??????????????????????T1???5,???w?k1870??T,1871????1875?????w ?????4??????,?????????????????????????;???????????????4?????4???pT1ie?????????;3?D?????? ?2:(1)?w???4??????????????????????????,???????????;????T1(2)?w???B???????????????????4?? ?p?????????.T1(3)?k???k????????????,?????T?????????????wT1inTF27Ty ???????D?????;???????????B?? ?D???????3?????????????4?????p,???k???????????????.?????????4?????????????)????????????,?? ?????????????k???D?????.????T1?k???????;???;????????,???T1954???????????????k???6?9?N???? ???????????.?????????u14????????????????T1 ?u14?????????????)???S?D?????p???o????,?8?F???S???????????p??????????T1?????;???T?9?? ???????,?w???????1??????,?????6?u14???????????????f???????)???????????????w?)?????o????T1 ????,ie?????;?H?D?????????f:(1)???????0???k????????????????iY??ia?CT1(2)?k?????(,???????7?? ???????o,?????0?????????????????k?o???????7???o?????BT1inTF28Ty ?????????????w???????????H??,?) ???????T???????????????u14??????????????????ie??in???9????????,?8?F?????????7???0???????? ??????????,???????????k???Y?5???????????C?????k,?????Y?5???.?????????w?f???;???????)T1???? ?????????k???6?r????????????(Lochnerv.NrewYork)????,?H?????B???0?:????????????????,??? ??u 14???????????????????????????l???p,?8?????[?????????????????????f?6???????????F??????,?? ???????????????:???oT1 ?k????????????????,?????7???S?5?p?????p?6?????2??????,?????7???u???l?S???m?????p?????? ?????k?o????,?6???0???????;???????????m???????????????????????????5?????????????BT1?????? ???????k1873???????w?????????6?C,?H?????M?????e?????????w???????s??????????T1?????F?????9 ?????p????????????????,???????????????o???4?;???????:?????w?f????????????????