清华会议分级

清华大学计算机科学与技术系 顶级/一流/重要会议列表(征求意见稿) 版本 0.8 2009 年 7 月 5 日 目录 1. 会议列表说明 ........................................................................................................................ 2 2. 顶级会议列表 (Rank1) ..................................................................................................... 4 3. 一流会议列表(Rank1.5) .................................................................................................. 6 4. 重要会议列表(Rank2) ....................................................................................................... 9 5. 部分分析后未列入的会议 ............................................................................................. 13 6. 按领域会议排序 ................................................................................................................ 16 附件：清华大学计算机系排序结果计算方法 ................................................................... 24 2 1. 会议列表说明 列表中 rank1表示顶级会议，rank1.5表示一流会议，rank2表示重要 会议。总共评价会议 1202个，确定顶级会议候选 42个，一流会议候选 48 个，重要会议候选 82个。 列表的生成采用量化标准＋定性分析的方法  量化指标包括：Citeseer 给出的排序结果、清华大学计算机系计算的排 序结果（按照 SCI引用因子的计算方式计算的 IF排序，计算方法见附 录）、三所大学（MIT、UCLA、NUS）的排序结果。各个列表中的数据统 计见下表。  定性分析由计算机系组织各所代表进行讨论，主要进行了三次讨论，参加 讨论的人员包括：孙茂松、陈文光、冯建华、唐杰、王建勇、徐明伟、 任丰原、刘永进、张敏、崔勇和白晓颖。  部分会议的引用因子满足进入 rank2 的条件，但参与前期讨论的老师都不 熟悉该会议，暂时列为待确认 rank2会议。  最后 rank1, rank1.5, rank2 将最多只保留 300个会议。 Rank1 Rank2 MIT 38 0 UCLA 91 93 NUS 59 96 Citeseer 覆盖的会 议 965 THU（清华大学） 覆盖的会议 1202 具体评估指标： （1）rank1 *IF 3.5以上，且其领域不是非常窄 *IF >= 1.5, 且该领域没有其它明显强于此会议的其他会议 *0.8<=IF<1.5,且在作为参考的 3所大学（MIT, UCLA, NTU）的列表中都列为 RANK1的会议 3 （2）rank1.5 不在 rank1 中的会议，如果符合下面的条件，其 RANK为 1.5 *IF >= 1.2,且领域不是非常窄 *IF >=0.9,且领域不是非常窄，且在作为参考的 3所大学（MIT, UCLA, NTU） 的列表中不只被列做 RANK2 *IF >= 0.6，且在至少一个参考列表中列为 RANK1 （3）rank 2 不在 rank1 和 rank 1.5 中的会议，如果符合下面的条件，其 RANK为 2 *IF >= 0.50 *IF >= 0.25，且至少有一个参考列表给 RANK2或以上 4 2. 顶级会议列表 (Rank1) 会议缩写 会议全称 每年平均 发表篇数 影响因子 1. OSDI Operating Systems Design and Implementation 27 7.54 2. SOSP Symposium on Operating Systems Principles 22 7.09 3. SIGCOMM Special Interest Group on Data Communication 31 7.06 4. MOBICOM Mobile Computing and Networking 27 6.67 5. SIGGRAPH Annual Conference on Computer Graphics 87 6.11 6. NSDI Networked Systems Design and Implementation 27 5.45 7. SIGMOD ACM SIGMOD International Conference on Management of Data 63 5.08 8. POPL Symposium on Principles of Programming Languages 31 4.27 9. PODS Symposium on Principles of Database Systems 30 4.06 10. WWW International World Wide Web Conference 84 4.01 11. CCS ACM Conference on Computer and Communications Security 38 4.01 12. VLDB International Conference on Very Large Data Bases 94 3.83 13. ASPLOS Architectural Support for Programming Languages and Operating Systems 33 3.42 14. HPCA International Symposium on High-Performance Computer Architecture 30 3.37 15. FAST USENIX Conference on File and Storage Technologies 20 3.25 16. PLDI SIGPLAN Conference on Programming Language Design and Implementation 32 3.22 17. OOPSLA Conference on Object-Oriented Programming Systems, Languages, and Applications 23 2.85 18. KDD Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining 48 2.58 19. PPOPP Principles & Practice of Parallel Programming 24 2.49 20. INFOCOM International Conference on Computer Communication 235 2.43 21. CRYPTO International Cryptology Conference 35 2.35 22. SIGIR Research and Development in Information Retrieval 63 2.33 23. IJCAI International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence 214 2.17 24. ICDE International Conference on Data Engineering 79 2.10 25. SIGMETRICS Measurement and Modeling of Computer Systems 29 1.90 26. SODA Symposium on Discrete Algorithms 124 1.85 27. STOC ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing 81 1.83 28. FOCS IEEE Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science 67 1.80 29. CVPR Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition 60 1.76 30. MICRO International Symposium on Microarchitecture 34 1.74 5 31. SIGSOFT FSE ACM SIGSOFT International Symposium on the Foundations of Software Engineering 29 1.73 32. ICCV International Conference on Computer Vision 122 1.70 33. Ubicomp International Conference on Ubiquitous Computing 37 1.67 34. ISCA International Symposium on Computer Architecture 36 1.63 35. ACL Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics 97 1.62 36. COLT Conference on Learning Theory 37 1.56 37. *DAC Design Automation Conference 165 1.45 38. *ICML International Conference on Machine Learning 118 1.44 39. *ICSE International Conference on Software Engineering 50 1.25 40. *UAI Uncertainty in Artificial Intelligence 75 1.14 41. *AAAI the Association for the Advancement of Artificial Intelligence 191 0.96 42. *NIPS Neural Information Processing Systems 224 0.83 *这些会议虽然影响因子值较低，但在作为参考的 3 所大学（MIT, UCLA, NTU）的列表中都列为 RANK1，因此建议也作为我系的 Rank1 会议。 6 3. 一流会议列表(Rank1.5) 会议缩写 会议全称 每年篇数 影响因子 1. IPTPS International workshop on Peer-To-Peer Systems （方向较窄，在一个参考列表中 RANK2） 27 5.79 2. SI3D Symposium on Interactive 3D Graphics （方向较窄,已有 SIGGRAPH 在 RANK1 中） 10 4.32 3. MobiHoc Interational Symposium on Mobile Ad Hoc Networking and Computing （移动网络与计算方面的会议，已有 MOBICOM 在 RANK1 中） 24 3.87 4. AOSD Aspect-Oriented Software Development （领域较窄，软件工程领域 ICSE 在 RANK1 中） 17 3.71 5. EUROSYS EUROSYS （已有 OSDI,SOSP 在 RANK1 中） 26 3.65 6. USENIX USENIX Annual Technical Conference, General Track （操作系统领域的会议，已有 OSDI,SOSP 在 RANK1 中） 23 3.34 7. SENSYS ACM SenSys （领域较窄，RANK1 中 SIGCOMM，INFOCOMM 可涵盖） 23 3.19 8. USENIX Security Symposium USENIX Security Symposium （安全方面的会议，相关领域已有 CCS 和 S&P 在 RANK1 中） 22 2.85 9. CSFW Computer Security Foundations Workshop (在两个参考列表中 RANK2) 15 2.72 10. EC ACM Conference on Electronic Commerce （方向较窄） 26 2.54 11. NDSS Network and Distributed System Security Symposium （分布式系统安全会议，进入 RANK1.5 的理由同 上） 15 2.45 12. ISSTA International Symposium on Software Testing and Analysis （方向较窄） 19 2.44 13. ISWC International Semantic Web Conference （领域较窄，WWW 在 RANK1 中可覆盖） 43 2.27 14. CAV Computer Aided Verification (领域较窄) 35 2.27 15. ECOOP European Conference on Object-Oriented Programming （在一个列表中为 RANK2， and one RANK1） 41 1.94 16. IMC Internet Measurement Conference/Workshop (IMC/IMW) 34 1.86 17. PODC Symposium on Principles of Distributed Computing （领域较窄，rank1 中 SOSP、OSDI 可涵盖） 39 1.82 18. SC Supercomputing （超级计算最好的会议，可由 RANK1 中 PPOPP 62 1.80 7 覆盖） 19. ESOP European Symposium on Programming （在两个列表中为 RANK2） 24 1.74 20. Middleware Middleware (领域较窄，rank1 中 SOSP、OSDI 可涵盖) 23 1.67 21. S&P IEEE Symposium on Security and Privacy 22 1.64 22. PACT International Conference on Parallel Architectures and Compilation Techniques 18 1.62 23. ECCV European Conference on Computer Vision 206 1.47 24. UIST ACM Symposium on User Interface Software and Technology 28 1.46 25. LICS Logic in Computer Science 39 1.43 26. SCA The ACM SIGGRAPH / Eurographics Symposium on Computer Animation 37 1.40 27. RECOMB Research in Computational Molecular Biology 37 1.34 28. ICNP IEEE International Conference on Network Protocols 33 1.33 29. SPAA ACM Symposium on Parallel Algorithms and Architectures 39 1.32 30. ICDT International Conference on Database Theory 25 1.28 31. *MM ACM Multimedia 54 1.23 32. HPDC IEEE International Symposium on High Performance Distributed Computing 30 1.22 33. EUROCRYPT Theory and Application of Cryptographic Techniques 34 1.20 34. ICFP International Conference on Functional Programming 24 1.16 35. ICDCS International Conference on Distributed Computing Systems 77 1.15 36. CONCUR International Conference on Concurrency Theory 31 1.02 37. RTSS IEEE Real-Time Systems Symposium 38 1.02 38. *KR Principles of Knowledge Representation and Reasoning 52 0.92 39. *RTAS IEEE Real Time Technology and Applications Symposium 37 0.89 40. *ISMB Intelligent Systems in Molecular Biology 53 0.88 41. *CHI Computer Human Interaction 163 0.97 42. *ICDM IEEE International Conference on Data Mining 64 0.95 43. *CIKM International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management 70 0.91 44. *ICLP International Conference on Logic Programming 55 0.82 8 45. *ICALP International Colloquium on Automata, Languages and Programming 67 0.74 46. *MobiSys The International Conference on Mobile Systems, Applications, and Services 19 0.73 47. *ICCAD International Conference on Computer Aided Design 114 0.72 48. *COLING International Conference on Computational Linguistics 117 0.67 *在作为参考的 3 所大学（MIT, UCLA, NTU）的列表中,至少有一个列表都列为 RANK1 9 4. 重要会议列表(Rank2) 会议缩写 会议全称 每年篇数 影响因子 1. AAMAS Autonomous Agents and Multi-agent Systems 139 1.42 2. ECSCW European Conference on Computer Supported Cooperative Work 22 1.22 3. CIDR Conference on Innovative Data Systems Research （参考列表中无） 25 1.19 4. CADE Conference on Automated Deduction （一个列表中 RANK2） 39 1.19 5. TACAS Tools and Algorithms for Construction and Analysis of Systems (两个列表中 RANK2) 36 1.15 6. SAS Static Analysis Symposium （方向较窄，在一个参考列表中 rank2） 27 1.13 7. AOSE Agent-Oriented Software Engineering 25 1.11 8. SDM SIAM International Conference on Data Mining (一个列表中 Rank2) 59 1.10 9. CGO Code Generation and Optimization 27 1.07 10. CSCW Conference on Computer Supported Cooperative Work （一个列表中 RANK2） 59 1.06 11. MDM Mobile Data Management 72 1.03 12. IEEE Visualization IEEE Visualization 72 1.03 13. EDBT Extending Database Technology （一个列表中 RANK2） 66 1.02 14. NOSSDAV Network and Operating System Support for Digital Audio and Video （一个列表中 RANK2） 23 1.01 15. PADL Practical Aspects of Declarative Languages （一个列表中 RANK2） 17 1.01 16. Hypertext ACM Conference on Hypertext 35 0.98 17. Pervasive Computing Pervasive Computing （参考列表中无） 49 0.98 18. ESORICS European Symposium on Research in Computer Security （一个列表中 RANK2） 22 0.96 19. ASIACRYPT The Annual International Conference on the Theory and Application of Cryptology & Information Security （一个列表中 RANK2） 33 0.93 20. ISPD International Symposium on Physical Design （在一个列表中为 rank2） 22 0.92 21. Grid Computing Grid Computing 47 0.90 22. HotOS Workshop on Hot Topics in Operating Systems 30 0.88 10 23. FoSSaCS International Conference on FOUNDATIONS OF SOFTWARE SCIENCE AND COMPUTATION STRUCTURES （两个列表中 RANK2） 34 0.88 24. ESEC/SIGSOFT FSE European Software Engineering Conference and the ACM SIGSOFT International Symposium on Foundations of Software Engineering 47 0.87 25. CASES Compilers, Architecture, and Synthesis for Embedded Systems 31 0.86 26. CIVR ACM International Conference on Image and Video Retrieval 83 0.85 27. HLT-NAACL Human Language Technology conference / North American chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics annual meeting 149 0.82 28. HSCC Hybrid Systems: Computation and Control 42 0.80 29. ICS International Conference on Supercomputing 34 0.78 30. FCCM Field-Programmable Custom Computing Machines 39 0.77 31. FSTTCS Foundations of Software Technology and Theoretical Computer Science 34 0.76 32. TCC Theory of Cryptography Conference 22 0.74 33. CoopIS Conference on Cooperative Information Systems 120 0.73 34. CONTEXT Conference on Modeling and Using Context 35 0.72 35. Information Hiding Information Hiding 26 0.69 36. FGR International Conference on Automatic Face and Gesture Recognition 82 0.69 37. CC(conference) Compiler Construction 20 0.69 38. DSN Dependable Systems and Networks 45 0.67 39. MSWiM International Workshop on Modeling Analysis and Simulation of Wireless and Mobile Systems 32 0.66 40. SRDS Symposium on Reliability in Distributed Software 29 0.65 41. 3DIM International Conference on 3-D Imaging and Modeling 61 0.65 42. MFCS Mathematical Foundations of Computer Science （在一个列表中为 rank2） 48 0.65 43. Euro-Par European Conference on Parallel Processing （在一个列表中为 rank2） 119 0.64 44. FME Formal Methods Europe （一个列表 RANK1） 38 0.64 45. RANDOM Randomization and Approximation Techniques in Computer Science 33 0.63 46. DATE Design, Automation, and Test in Europe 302 0.63 47. MASCOTS Modeling, Analysis, and Simulation On Computer and Telecommunication Systems 42 0.62 48. ICAPS International Conference on Automated Planning and Scheduling （一个列表 RANK1） 35 0.62 49. ECML European Conference on Machine Learning 45 0.62 11 50. RTA Rewriting Techniques and Applications 24 0.61 51. STACS International Symposium on Theoretical Aspects of Computer Science 44 0.61 52. PKDD Principles of Data Mining and Knowledge Discovery 47 0.60 53. ACSAC Annual Computer Security Applications Conference 34 0.60 54. ECIR European Conference on Information Retrieval 41 0.60 55. WABI Workshop on Algorithms in Bioinformatics （在一个列表中为 rank2） 38 0.59 56. JCDL ACM/IEEE Joint Conference on Digital Libraries （两个列表中为 RANK2） 70 0.53 57. ASE Automated Software Engineering 90 0.52 58. CLUSTER Cluster Computing （在两个个列表中为 rank2） 45 0.50 59. ISSS International Symposium on Systems Synthesis （在一个列表中为 rank2） 42 0.44 60. FPGA International Symposium on Field Programmable Gate Arrays （一个列表中为 RANK1） 55 0.43 61. WOWMOM International Symposium on a World of Wireless, Mobile and Multimedia Networks 49 0.41 62. MICCAI Medical Image Computing and Computer-Assisted Intervention 222 0.39 63. ESA European Symposium on Algorithms （一个列表中为 RANK1） 80 0.38 64. DCC Data Compression Conference 45 0.36 65. CGI Computer Graphics International （一个列表中为 RANK2） 40 0.34 66. IPCO Integer Programming and Combinatorial Optimization （两个列表中为 RANK2） 30 0.33 67. ICPP International Conference on Parallel Processing （两个列表中为 RANK2） 67 0.31 68. IWQoS International Workshop on Quality of Service （一个列表中为 RANK2） 29 0.31 69. EMSOFT International Workshop on Embedded Systems （一个列表中为 RANK1） 21 0.31 70. ISSAC International Symposium on Symbolic and Algebraic Computation （一个列表中为 RANK1） 46 0.30 71. ICCCN International Conference on Computer Communications and Networks （两个列表中为 RANK2） 98 0.30 72. IPSN Information Processing in Sensor Networks （一个列表中为 RANK2） 36 0.30 73. IFM Integrated Formal Methods （一个列表中为 RANK2） 22 0.30 74. ICIP International Conference on Image Processing 666 0.29 12 （一个列表中为 RANK2） 75. CODES+ISSS International Conference on Hardware-Software Codesign and System Synthesis （在一个列表中为 rank2） 47 0.29 76. ER Intl Conf on Conceptual Modeling (ER) （一个列表中为 RANK2） 46 0.28 77. IPDPS Intl Parallel and Dist Processing Symp （一个列表中为 RANK2） 80 0.28 78. EMNLP Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing (一个列表中为 RANK2）) 64 0.28 79. EuroGraphics Symposium on geometry processing EuroGraphics Symposium on geometry processing 28 0.28 80. EACL Conference of the European Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics. （一个列表中为 RANK2） 109 0.27 81. IEEE Symposium on Computer Arithmetic IEEE Symposium on Computer Arithmetic （在一个列表中为 rank1） 34 0.27 82. Pacific Graphics Pacific Conference on Computer Graphics and Applications （一个列表中为 RANK2） 61 0.26 13 5. 部分分析后未列入的会议 以下为部分分析过的会议，部分会议的引用因子满足进入相应会议列表 的条件，但参与前期讨论的老师都不熟悉该会议，暂时列为待确认，老 师们可以根据本文第一部分所述规则，建议自己熟悉的会议进入相应的 列表。 部分会议的影响因子较低，不能列入 rank1，1.5和 2。 会议缩写 会议全称 每年篇数 影响因子 1. 1 VMCAI Verification, Model Checking and Abstract Interpretation 27 1.76 2. PET Privacy Enhancing Technologies 19 1.73 3. WMCSA Workshop on Mobile Computing Systems and Applications 17 1.57 4. SPIN SPIN 21 1.50 5. RAID International Symposium On Recent Advances in Intrusion Detection 16 1.42 6. PKC Public Key Cryptography 29 1.35 7. POLICY Policies for Distributed Systems and Networks 30 1.30 8. IUI International conference on intelligent user interfaces 37 1.18 9. CT-RSA The Cryptographer's Track at RSA Conference 25 1.03 10. JSSPP Job Scheduling Strategies for Parallel Processing 12 0.95 11. DISC International Symposium on Distributed Computing 47 0.85 12. FMCAD Formal Methods in Computer-Aided Design 29 0.76 13. CMPB Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine 87 0.01 14. AMEC Agent-Mediated Electronic Commerce 21 0.98 15. Financial Cryptograph y Financial Cryptography 17 0.90 16. PPDP Principles and Practice of Declarative Programming 31 0.88 17. SACMAT Symposium on Access Control Models and Technologies 22 0.87 18. PEPM Partial Evaluation and Semantic-Based Program Manipulation 23 0.84 19. PSB Pacific Symposium on Biocomputing 29 0.79 20. GPCE Generative Programming and Component Engineering 28 0.76 21. CCC IEEE Conference on Computational Complexity 19 0.71 22. ICGT International Conference on Graph Transformation 32 0.70 23. RobuCup RobuCup 30 0.68 24. ETRA Eye Tracking Research & Application 19 0.66 14 25. ATAL Agent Theories, Architectures, and Languages 28 0.65 26. ILP International Workshop on Inductive Logic Programming 24 0.61 27. CHARME Conference on Correct Hardware Design and Verification Methods 16 0.61 28. ISMIR International Symposium/Conference on Music Information Retrieval 23 0.60 29. CPE Computer Performance Evaluation 41 0.60 30. WCRE Working Conference on Reverse Engineering 39 0.59 31. CPM Annual Symposium on Combinatorial Pattern Matching 49 0.58 32. DLog Description Logics 93 0.57 33. JELIA Logics in Artificial Intelligence 16 0.57 34. AP2PC Agents and Peer-to-Peer Computing 40 0.55 35. TES Workshops on technologies for E-Services 39 0.52 36. LPAR Logic Programming and Automated Reasoning 63 0.51 37. LPNMR Logic Programming and Non-monotonic Reasoning 18 0.48 38. ICSM International Conference on Software Maintenance （在一个列表中为 rank2） 30 0.47 39. CSL Computer Science Logic （在一个列表中为 rank2） 63 0.41 40. FSE Fast Software Encryption 27 0.40 41. TPHOLS Theorem Proving in Higher Order Logics 34 0.39 42. CHES Cryptographic Hardware and Embedded Systems 13 0.38 43. ECAI European Conference on Artificial Intelligence （在一个列表中为 rank2） 35 0.37 44. PASTE Workshop on Program Analysis For Software Tools and Engineering 62 0.37 45. FASE Fundamental Approaches to Software Engineering （在一个列表中为 rank2） 29 0.36 46. BIBE IEEE International Conference on Bioinformatics and Bioengineering 29 0.33 47. ICSR International Conference on Software Reuse （在一个列表中为 rank2） 14 0.32 48. EGSR EuroGraphics Symposium on rendering 41 0.32 49. DAS Document Analysis Systems （在一个列表中为 rank2） 92 0.31 50. WACV Workshop on Applications of Computer Vision （在一个列表中为 rank2） 36 0.31 51. ALT Algorithmic Learning Theory （在一个列表中为 rank2） 79 0.30 52. APPROX Approximation Algorithms for Combinatorial Optimization （在一个列表中为 rank2） 26 0.30 53. ISAAC International Symposium on Algorithms and Computation 50 0.29 15 （在一个列表中为 rank2） 54. ICCL IEEE Intl Conf on Computer Languages （在一个列表中为 rank2） 24 0.28 55. DNA DNA Cosmputing （在一个列表中为 rank2） 50 0.25 56. VLSI IEEE Symp VLSI Circuits （在两个个列表中为 rank2） 28 0.2 57.